Technology News

T-Mobile illegally imposed 50 GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says

The settlement, announced this week by New York Governor Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James, concludes an extensive investigation by the Office of the Attorney General (OAG). The probe determined that T-Mobile had implemented a 50 GB-per-month data cap on its specialized low-income broadband offerings, subsequently throttling connection speeds to a crawl of 600 Kbps once the limit was reached. This practice directly contravened the requirements set forth in the New York Affordable Broadband Act (ABA), which mandates that internet service providers (ISPs) offering service to low-income households must provide high-speed, reliable connectivity at standardized, affordable price points.

The Scope of the Affordable Broadband Act

The New York Affordable Broadband Act is a landmark piece of legislation designed to bridge the digital divide for the state’s most vulnerable residents. It requires any internet provider operating in New York with a subscriber base of at least 20,000 customers to offer specific tiers of service to income-eligible households. Under the law, these providers are obligated to offer a $15-per-month plan providing speeds of at least 25 Mbps, or a $20-per-month plan offering speeds of 200 Mbps or greater.

By enforcing a 50 GB data cap, T-Mobile effectively rendered the promised 25 Mbps service unusable for modern households after only a few days of typical activity, such as streaming video, participating in video conferencing, or managing household digital tasks. The OAG’s investigation revealed that, for a standard family or individual user, the 50 GB allotment could be exhausted in as little as four days. Once that threshold was crossed, the speed reduction to 600 Kbps—a rate reminiscent of the dial-up era—prevented users from accessing essential online services, thereby defeating the purpose of the state’s mandated affordable broadband initiative.

A Chronology of Compliance and Enforcement

The road to this settlement has been long and marked by significant industry resistance. New York first moved to enforce the Affordable Broadband Act in January 2025, following a protracted four-year legal battle against major broadband industry lobby groups. Organizations including CTIA, the wireless industry association that represents T-Mobile and other carriers, had challenged the law in federal court, arguing that state-level regulations on broadband pricing were preempted by federal authority.

The legal impasse was only resolved in late 2024, when the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the industry’s challenge, effectively greenlighting New York’s enforcement efforts. Despite the finality of the court’s decision, compliance among ISPs has been uneven. The OAG investigation into T-Mobile began in June 2025, after the New York Department of Public Service relayed concerns about the carrier’s restrictive practices.

T-Mobile illegally imposed 50 GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says

Throughout the inquiry, state investigators discovered that T-Mobile was not only throttling speeds but was also geographically restricting the availability of these low-income plans. The company had limited the ABA-compliant plans exclusively to areas where it had deployed 5G home internet, despite having the capability to provide the required 25 Mbps speeds over its 4G (LTE) network in other regions. Furthermore, the investigation uncovered evidence that T-Mobile had actively configured its website to prevent search engines from indexing the pages dedicated to the ABA-compliant plans. This "noindex" coding made it intentionally difficult for eligible New Yorkers to locate or enroll in the programs to which they were legally entitled.

The Settlement Terms

Under the terms of the settlement, T-Mobile has agreed to a comprehensive remediation plan. The company is required to eliminate the 50 GB data caps and the associated speed throttling for all ABA-compliant plans within 120 days. Additionally, T-Mobile must expand the availability of these plans to cover all residential locations where the company offers fixed wireless internet service, regardless of whether the infrastructure is 5G or 4G.

To ensure transparency, T-Mobile must remove all search engine restrictions on its affordable broadband landing pages and include prominent links to these plans on the main pages where it advertises its standard home internet products. While the settlement includes a detailed list of the OAG’s findings, T-Mobile did not formally admit to any wrongdoing as part of the agreement.

In an official statement, T-Mobile remarked, "We have a long history of helping customers in New York stay connected through low-cost broadband, and we’re updating our plan to meet the state’s requirements while maintaining the same low price. We’ve reached an agreement with the New York attorney general that builds on that commitment, provides greater clarity around our offering, and makes the plan available to more eligible customers."

Implications and Future Regulatory Challenges

The resolution of this case serves as a warning to other ISPs operating within New York. The OAG has made it clear that it maintains the authority to pursue litigation if these terms are violated, with the potential for civil penalties reaching up to $1,000 per violation. This aggressive enforcement stance underscores the state’s commitment to ensuring that digital equity is not merely a legal theory but a tangible reality for its citizens.

However, the broader regulatory landscape remains volatile. There is ongoing tension between state-level consumer protection laws and federal policy. Certain segments of the telecommunications industry are looking toward the federal government for relief, particularly in light of arguments that state price regulations may conflict with federal funding programs, such as the $42 billion Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program. While the federal government has signaled potential resistance to state-level broadband regulations, states like California and New York continue to push back, asserting their sovereign right to regulate utility-like services within their borders.

T-Mobile illegally imposed 50 GB cap on low-income home Internet plan, NY says

A Pattern of Pricing Disputes

This settlement is not the first time T-Mobile has faced legal scrutiny from New York authorities regarding its billing and marketing practices. Just last month, the state concluded a separate agreement with T-Mobile regarding the company’s "Price Guarantee" marketing. That investigation found that T-Mobile had advertised certain plans as having a "lifetime price guarantee" between 2017 and 2019, only to raise prices for those customers in 2024.

In that instance, the state secured a deal that provided approximately $38 million in estimated value to affected customers, including reimbursement options and a locked-in price rate until May 2029. The recurring nature of these disputes highlights an increasing friction between T-Mobile’s business strategies and the consumer protection mandates enforced by state regulators.

Analysis: The Future of Affordable Connectivity

The T-Mobile settlement marks a significant win for digital advocacy. By forcing one of the nation’s largest wireless carriers to remove artificial barriers to entry, New York has demonstrated that state law can be an effective tool in forcing large corporations to comply with accessibility mandates.

As high-speed internet becomes as fundamental to daily life as water or electricity, the struggle over "affordable" access is expected to intensify. With the current administration’s stance on state-level deregulation, it is possible that future legal battles will shift from state houses to federal courts, testing the limits of what states can legally require of private telecommunications firms. For now, however, the thousands of New Yorkers who rely on T-Mobile for their home internet will see a tangible improvement in service quality, free from the constraints of arbitrary data caps that previously limited their digital lives.

Related Articles

Back to top button
PlanMon
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.